Book nine is simply extraordinary. As Malcolm Willcock says, “In many ways it is the finest in the Iliad and is a self-contained whole.” To look at Book Nine from a bird’s eye view, we see Nestor propose that Agamemnon make amends with Achilles; Ag agrees and puts together a staggering shining ransom; Odysseus, Phoenix, and Ajax are selected to be part of the embassy that asks Achilles to return. Each man makes a speech and Achilles offers each a reply. To Odysseus he says that we will return home tomorrow; after Phoenix’s speech, his stance softens and he says that he will make his decision in the morning; after Ajax’s speech, he says that he will not assist the Achaeans until Hector begins to set fire to the Myrmidon ships; meaning that he won’t sail home and that he has ultimately decided in favor of a short and glorious life rather than a long life without undying fame. The results of the conversation are then reported back to Agamemnon.
Share this post
An Introduction to Homer's Iliad Bk 9
montanaclassicalcollege.substack.com
1×
0:00
-33:16
An Introduction to Homer's Iliad Bk 9
On the Problem of Honor
Jan 04, 2024
Transcript
No transcript...
Montana Classical College
Promoting noble deeds, the understanding of nature, and the protection of the nation state.
Promoting noble deeds, the understanding of nature, and the protection of the nation state.Listen on
Substack App
RSS Feed
Recent Episodes
An Introduction to Homer's Iliad Bk 9